Saylorsburg Lake House Hotel: From Lakeside Retreat to Haunted Legend

Discover the haunting history of the Lake House Hotel in Saylorsburg, Pennsylvania. Once captured in a 1915 photograph by Lewis Reed, this former lakeside resort is now home to the Hotel of Horror, one of the Pocono Mountains’ most legendary haunted attractions.

Saylorsburg Lake House Hotel, 1915

Saylorsburg Lake House Hotel. Photo taken by Lewis Reed, 1915.

More than a century ago, a quiet corner of Saylorsburg, Pennsylvania, drew vacationers seeking relaxation beside the sparkling waters of Saylors Lake. Long before it became known as the Hotel of Horror, the Lake House Hotel was one of the region’s most recognizable landmarks; a grand, three-story resort that welcomed travelers for generations.

One of the earliest known photographs of the Lake House was taken in 1915 by Lewis Reed, founder of Reed Brothers Dodge in Rockville, Maryland. Reed, an accomplished photographer with an eye for architectural detail, captured the hotel at a time when it stood as a proud symbol of the Pocono Mountains’ growing popularity as a leisure destination. His image shows a sturdy, stately building surrounded by calm and charm; a far cry from the ghostly atmosphere the site is known for today.

Built in the early 1800s, the Lake House Hotel served as a central gathering place for both locals and vacationers. It offered not only comfortable lodging but also fine dining, boating, and dancing by the lake. The hotel’s reputation grew through the 19th and early 20th centuries, and by the time Lewis Reed visited, it had already become a well-established destination for city dwellers looking to escape the summer heat.

The Lake House Hotel in Saylorsburg, site of Hotel of Horror. Google image capture, 2025

The Lake House Hotel in Saylorsburg, site of Hotel of Horror. Google image, 2025

From Lakeside Retreat to Haunted Legend

The Lake House’s story took a darker turn as decades passed. Local legend claims that during World War II, most of the hotel’s staff enlisted in the Pennsylvania National Guard, leaving behind only a caretaker. The tale goes that nearby asylum inmates escaped and sought refuge in the hotel, leading to a series of mysterious and tragic events. Whether rooted in truth or simply folklore, the story added a haunting aura to the building’s legacy.

By the late 20th century, the once-elegant hotel had fallen into disrepair. In 1990, it reopened briefly as an antique co-op before being transformed into a haunted attraction. Since 1992, the Hotel of Horror and Altered Nightmares have operated within its historic walls, breathing new life into the old building each Halloween season. Visitors now walk through the same corridors that Lewis Reed once photographed, only today, they’re filled with eerie sounds, flickering lights, and the echoes of imagined ghosts.

More than just a haunted house, the Lake House Hotel remains a remarkable link to Pennsylvania’s past. Through Lewis Reed’s 1915 photograph, we catch a glimpse of its former grandeur; a moment frozen in time before history, legend, and imagination intertwined to make it one of the Poconos’ most enduring stories.

To all the readers of this blog: Have a spooky, enjoyable and very safe Halloween!

Happy Halloween

Historic Tracks: Gettysburg Lincoln Railroad Station Then and Now

The Gettysburg Lincoln Railroad Station is more than just a building, it’s a piece of American history. From Abraham Lincoln’s famous journey to deliver the Gettysburg Address to the thousands of visitors who pass through today, this station has seen it all. In this “Then & Now” post, we take a look at how this iconic landmark has changed (or stayed the same!) over the years, giving us a fresh perspective on a place that helped shape our nation’s story.

Gettysburg Lincoln Railroad Station (THEN): Captured by photographer Lewis Reed in 1914, this remarkable image shows a crowd gathered along the tracks outside the Gettysburg Lincoln Railroad Station. The station’s elegant Italianate architecture with its arched windows, decorative brickwork, and central cupola stands prominently in the background. A steam locomotive waits at the platform as men in suits and bowler hats fill the scene, evoking an era when rail travel was both essential and ceremonial. The photograph offers a vivid glimpse into early 20th-century life in Gettysburg, when the railroad still served as the town’s vital connection to the wider world.

Gettysburg Lincoln Railroad Station

A historic photograph of the Gettysburg Lincoln Railroad Station captured by Lewis Reed in 1914, showing the depot in its early 20th-century setting.

Gettysburg Lincoln Railroad Station (NOW): More than a century later, the restored Gettysburg Lincoln Railroad Station continues to welcome visitors; though today, they come not to board trains, but to step back in time. The station now operates as a museum and visitor center, preserving the story of Abraham Lincoln’s arrival to deliver the Gettysburg Address in 1863. Its beautifully restored façade and carefully maintained details honor both its Civil War legacy and the generations that followed, ensuring this historic landmark remains a lasting link between past and present.

Gettysburg Railroad Lincoln Train Museum Today

Halloween History: Montgomery County 100 Years Ago

Have you ever wondered how families in Montgomery County marked Halloween 100 years ago? Thanks to a collection of photographs from Lewis Reed, we can journey back to the year 1914 and glimpse the traditions of that era.

At the start of the 20th century, Halloween costumes were simple, women usually donned their everyday attire enhanced with homemade masks. The concept of full costumes was just emerging, inspired by the popular masquerade balls of the early 1900s. It wasn’t until the 1920s and 1930s that manufactured costumes became widely available for purchase.

1900s Halloween costumes

Halloween, ca. 1914. These women are holding homemade Halloween masks for their upcoming celebration. Photo by Lewis Reed

In those days, a simple mask was all it took to join in the festivities. Curious about how your ancestors celebrated? Old newspapers provide wonderful insights into the customs and community spirit of the time, and Lewis Reed’s photos enrich this nostalgic look back.

Stores Well-Stocked for Festivities

Local stores prepared for the season by stocking Halloween essentials. Advertisements from the period featured costumes and masquerade suits for parties and social events, signaling that the holiday was well embraced.

1916 Halloween Costumes

The Washington Post, 30 October 1916

The photo below captures a Halloween gathering from around 1914. The image shows a group of family and friends dressed in early 20th-century attire, adorned with costumes and decorations typical of Halloween celebrations of the era. The costumes are homemade, featuring masks and hats that reflect the masquerade style popular at the time.

1900s Halloween

This photo captures a moment from a Halloween party over 100 years ago and is equal parts amusing and creepy. Photo by Lewis Reed

Dancing and Social Gatherings

Halloween was often celebrated with lively parties and dancing. Some society columns even listed the guests attending these events. A 1916 Halloween party described in The Evening Star painted a vibrant picture: rooms were decorated with autumn leaves, lanterns, chrysanthemums, and orange-and-black streamers. Guests played old-fashioned games, followed by gathering around a fireplace in darkness to be led through the house by a ghostly figure. The night concluded with music, dancing, and refreshments.

Refreshments included traditional pumpkin pies, molasses cookies, and even festive Halloween salads, demonstrating the importance of food to the celebrations.

Halloween Salad

The Evening Star, October 24, 1915

Mischievous Halloween Pranks

Mischief and pranks were also a notable aspect of Halloween in the early 1900s. Children, often referred to as “witches and goblins, ghosts and mischief-making youngsters,” were permitted a certain degree of revelry. However, some pranks were considered “downright bizarre” by modern standards, such as children knocking on doors and throwing flour at those who answered. This widespread mischief eventually led to a societal push by 1920 to re-frame Halloween as a holiday centered on community gatherings and festive parades, rather than unruly behavior. The shift aimed to channel the holiday’s energy into more organized and less disruptive forms of celebration.

1916 Halloween Pranks

The Evening Star, October 31, 1916

The Birth of Halloween Parades

By the 1920s, pranks had become too unruly, prompting communities to steer Halloween toward organized festivities, including parades. These events fostered safer, family-friendly celebrations focused on community gathering rather than mischief.

vintage Halloween mask

There is something undeniably creepy about this clown in sunglasses riding on a horse in a Halloween Parade. Location is unknown. Photo by Lewis Reed

The above intriguing image captures a performer dressed as a clown riding a horse during an early Halloween celebration. The costume features a striking pointed collar and a whimsical hat, but notably includes round dark sunglasses; an unusual and playful accessory for the era. This detail highlights the creativity and individuality often showcased in homemade Halloween costumes of the period, blending theatrical flair with a touch of modern whimsy.

Braddock Heights, Maryland Then & Now

Looking at old photographs is like opening a window to the past. They invite us to step back in time, sparking both wonder and amazement at how much the world around us has changed. For this post, I’ve paired one of Lewis Reed’s original photographs for the “then” view with a modern Google image for the “now.”

Braddock Heights (THEN): Braddock Heights is a small unincorporated community in Frederick County, Maryland, established around the turn of the 20th century as a popular mountain resort. In its early days, it offered visitors hotels, an amusement park, a skating rink, nature trails, and an observatory from which four states (Maryland, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and West Virginia) could be seen. It even boasted a small ski resort. The Hagerstown and Frederick Railway operated a trolley line connecting Frederick and Braddock Heights from 1896 to 1946. Today, with a population of about 5,000, the area remains known for its sweeping views of Frederick and the Monocacy and Middletown valleys. Braddock Heights takes its name from British General Edward Braddock (1695-1755), who passed through the region during the French and Indian War on April 29, 1755.

Braddock Heights as seen from Observatory, 1910

Braddock Heights viewed from the Observatory, with Middletown visible in the distance. Photograph by Lewis Reed, circa 1910.

Braddock Heights (NOW): Today, rush-hour traffic flows over the mountain along Alternate U.S. Route 40, stretching from Frederick and I-70 into the Middletown Valley, most of it passing right by the stone pillars at Maryland Avenue that mark the entrance to Braddock Heights.

View overlooking Middletown Valley along U.S. Route 40

Local Folklore: Fun Trivia about the Snallygaster

The Snallygaster is a legendary creature rooted in Maryland folklore, particularly in Frederick County and the Middletown Valley. Originating from the German settlers in the 1730s who called it a Schneller Geist meaning “quick spirit,” this fearsome beast is described as a half-bird, half-reptile chimera with razor-sharp teeth and sometimes octopus-like tentacles. The Snallygaster is said to silently swoop down from the sky, preying on livestock and occasionally people, with some early tales even claiming it sucked the blood of its victims.

In the early 1900s, the creature gained widespread notoriety through newspaper reports depicting it with enormous wings, a long pointed bill, steel-hook claws, and a single eye in the middle of its forehead, emitting screeches like a locomotive whistle. The creature was so infamous that the Smithsonian Institution reportedly offered a reward for its hide, and President Theodore Roosevelt considered hunting it himself.

Local farms still bear seven-pointed stars painted on barns, believed to be protective symbols meant to keep the Snallygaster at bay. Beyond scary stories, the legend has evolved into a cultural symbol celebrated today with events like the annual Snallygaster Festival in Frederick County, highlighting the area’s rich folklore heritage.

Though some of its tales have troubling historical contexts, including the use of the legend to instill fear in certain communities during segregation, the Snallygaster remains a memorable and intriguing figure in Maryland’s folklore landscape, blending myth, mystery, and history in one creature.

Snallygaster

Maryland’s legendary winged beast—half bird, half reptile.

Harvesting History: Pumpkin Picking in Pleasant Hills, 1920

Pumpkin Patch

Pumpkin picking in Thomas Kelly’s Pumpkin Patch, Darnestown, Maryland circa. early 1900s. Photo by Lewis Reed

Captured in this rare photograph are three men dressed in suits, standing among the pumpkins grown by farmer Thomas Kelly in Pleasant Hills, dating back to the early 1900s. This image provides a unique window into the rural life of Montgomery County, where farming and the seasonal rhythm of the land shaped the community’s way of life.

Thomas Kelly was a prominent figure who cultivated much of the land near the Pleasant Hills homestead. He was widely known for his “Kelly Corn” wagon, a summer staple stocked with fresh dairy products and vegetables, which traveled the local roads. Every August, his corn also played a key role in feeding attendees at the Montgomery County Fair, a popular local event.

As autumn rolled in, Kelly’s farm transformed into a vibrant pumpkin patch where locals and visitors came to select pumpkins for their homes. The tradition of pumpkin picking was not only about gathering produce but also experienced as an annual celebration of the harvest season. This photograph recalls that special connection to the land and the traditions that brought people together year after year.

Photographer Lewis Reed, the founder of Reed Brothers Dodge, captured moments like these that preserve the character and heritage of Montgomery County’s agricultural past. This image remains a poignant reminder of simpler times grounded in community, hard work, and seasonal bounty.